Skip to content

Joan Advincula

Criminology. Tech. Web3.

  • Home
  • Crim Notes
    • ChFo 102 Character Formation 2
      • Leadership and Management
        • Leadership vs Management
        • Principles of Leadership
        • Theories of Leadership
        • Leadership Styles
        • Management Styles
        • Efficient Management
        • Qualities of Leaders and Managers
      • Administration
        • Principles of Administration
        • Theories of Administration
        • Functions of Administration
        • Police Management
        • Division of Work
        • Authority and Responsibility
        • Unity of Command
        • Scalar Chain
    • FrSc 105 Lie Detection Techniques
      • Introduction to Lie Detection
        • Psychology of Lying
        • Lies and Liars
        • Ancient Methods of Detecting Deception
        • Other Methods
      • Fundamentals of Polygraphy
        • Definition of Relevant Terms
        • The Nervous System
        • Theory Behind the Polygraph
        • The Polygraph Instrument
        • General Uses
      • Reliability and Validity
        • Scientific Validity
        • Legal Aspects of Polygraph Use
        • Pros and Cons
  • Home
  • Crim Notes
  • FrSc 105 Lie Detection Techniques
  • Reliability and Validity

Reliability and Validity

The polygraph instrument is a scientific instrument that is designed to sense and record the physiological changes in the human body during questioning. The following are the objectives of a polygraph examination:

  • Obtain additional investigation leads to the facts of the case/offenses
  • Ascertain whether the subject is telling the truth
  • Verify and compare conflicting statement
  • Locate the fruits or tools of the crime and whereabouts of wanted persons
  • Identify other persons involved (e.g. accomplices)
  • Obtain valuable information from reluctant witnesses
  • Eliminate innocent suspects

In order to achieve these objectives, the polygraph must be subject to the rigorous testing of experts in the field so that it can become an acceptable scientific instrument.

In research, an object is considered reliable if its results are reproducible if used on a different occasion or by a different person. That is, you can expect it to perform consistently well.

An object is valid if it is logically or factually sound. Validity is the rating of how accurate an object measures what it is supposed to measure.

MeanThat & Authentic Data Science, 3.11 Validity and Reliability Of Research

In the context of the polygraph instrument, if we are inquiring on its reliability and validity, it means that we want to confirm whether it can be used by various people at various times and still produce trustworthy results, and whether it measures the body’s physiological changes correctly.

Or, in other words, we want to know whether polygraph examiners can consistently detect deception using the polygraph instrument.

Understandably, it is difficult to conduct objective research into the polygraph instrument due to the nature of how it attempts to detect deception.

Unlike ballistics research where it is easy to replicate fired bullets, it is markedly more difficult to simulate the psycho-physiological responses of a criminal suspect in a laboratory setting or in a mock crime situation. Doing it in a lab could diminish the actually body responses even if actual criminals are used in the study. When using non-criminals in a simulation, they would not have the same levels of fear and motivation as suspects would. Additionally, examination results from a polygraph examiner are generally not subject to full confirmation.

Various research today still show that the polygraph is not a valid tool for use in the criminal justice system or that its validity is immeasurable.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copyright © 2023 Joan Advincula.

Theme: Oceanly by ScriptsTown